Can you save too much for retirement?

by Pop on April 6, 2011

Post image for Can you save too much for retirement?

And can I contradict myself in a week?

When I was in college, I dressed like a homeless person. Now, I dress like I’m in college. It’s not that I can’t afford nicer clothes. Thankfully I’m well beyond the “no money” years. It’s just that I never really “upgraded” to the stuff most of my peers are wearing nowadays.

So I should be patting myself on the back, right? Living like a poor person—when you’re not—is one of those tried and true personal finance adages that mark classics like The Millionaire Next Door. The millionaires live like they’re not rich. They buy used cars. They eat at home. Then they retire early or spend retirement travelling the world because they’ve saved so much gosh darn money.

But sometimes left out of the discussion of saving, is how much is too much when you’re retirement planning.

To take it to an extreme and keep things simple, let’s say we’ve got a 25-year old making $60,000. He’s totally bought into saving like a madman and maxes out a Roth IRA and a 401k every year until he retires. Based on one, mainstream retirement calculator, that would give him about $8,900 per year per month once he retired at age 66—almost two and a half times what he used to live on at age 65.

He could fund two of his retirements, and still have half a retirement left over. Should we celebrate that?

The concept of “consumption smoothing”

I think most people would say “No.” The 25-year-old self was cheated out of current pleasures…his trip to Norway, his “grown-up” clothes…that would have been perfectly fine for him to buy. Instead, his 80-year-old self either goes on a spending binge, leaves a large inheritance, or tries to pay off St. Peter.

Instead, many economists consider the ideal savings amount to be that which “smooths” your consumption over your lifetime. In short, you want your quality of life in your 60s and beyond to be about as high as it was in your 30s.

At some point and to make things simple, personal finance gurus started to back out savings targets—like 10% or 20%—that would achieve consumption smoothing as long as the stock market hit certain rates of return.

Laurence Kotlikoff, a Boston University economist, a few years ago took it so far as to create an extremely comprehensive retirement calculator, that can show you how much you should consume every year into and through retirement based on the assumptions you put in. (Here’s the more basic, free version.)

Can you save too much for retirement? Yes! But in personal finance circles, it’s generally not “cool” to spend. A recent Wall Street Journal column derided people who buy iPad 2s (or is it iPads 2?). The logic: It’s really costing you $2,000 since you could have invested it instead! By that logic, I should really feel bad about my $5 lunch today—that could have been $20, after inflation, in 2041. This year, I will blow $7,200 of my future money on lunch. I’m such a moron.

The columnist’s logic assigns little to no value to present enjoyment, in favor of future enjoyment. That makes no sense.

Don’t get me wrong, this doesn’t apply to most people. Most Americans will retire with little to no savings. And those people shouldn’t be buying iPads. But given that you’re reading this blog, I’m betting you’re putting at least a bit away already, or at least thinking about putting a bit away.

Throw uncertainty into the mix, and suddenly saving “too much” seems impossible.

The idea of consumption smoothing has a major flaw, of course: uncertainty. We don’t know what stocks will return over the next decades. We don’t know where tax rates will be or if we’ll be in a car accident or if the roof will need to be replaced, etc.

Or perhaps a more dire situation: Imagine you’re a 53-year old staring down the newly proposed Republican budget. In 12 years, you were expecting Medicare. Bzzzzz. Wrong. Maybe you could have seen some sort of Medicare reform coming, but you probably didn’t predict the fairly random age-55 cutoff that would probably allow you to save thousands in insurance costs if you had only been born in 1956.

There are two ways to react to that uncertainty: To save as much as you can in case a worst-case scenario comes along or to save for a best-guess scenario and risk having to cut consumption if the dice come up snake eyes.

I’m saving for a “best guess”, with the reasonable safety measures of a year-long emergency fund, an annuity, etc. Sure, fate could frown on me, but I’m not willing to make a guaranteed sacrifice of reasonable happinesses today just to prepare for a possibly scary future. There’s a chance, my 66-year old self might be unhappy with the current me, but he’s going to have to deal with it.


{ 76 comments… read them below or add one }

Thuê xe 7 chỗ cần thơ đi sài gòn March 9, 2024 at 4:11 am

Thanks for sharing excellent informations. Your web-site is very cool. I am impressed by the details that you’ve on this site. It reveals how nicely you understand this subject. Bookmarked this website page, will come back for extra articles. You, my pal, ROCK! I found just the information I already searched everywhere and simply couldn’t come across. What a perfect web-site.

windshield replacement shop near me 28263 March 23, 2024 at 12:21 pm

You’ve opened my eyes to new perspectives. Thank you for the enlightenment!

auto glass shop near 27374 March 24, 2024 at 2:58 am

This article was a delightful enjoy reading. Your passion is clearly visible!

Auto Glass Shop Fort Bragg March 28, 2024 at 3:48 am

Your blog is a constant source of inspiration and knowledge. Thank you!

private investigator north carolina March 30, 2024 at 9:00 pm

You’ve opened my eyes to new perspectives. Thank you for the enlightenment!

how to know if your house is bugged March 31, 2024 at 9:43 am

Your thoughtful analysis has really made me think. Thanks for the great enjoy reading!

Local Windshield Replacement 27616 April 10, 2024 at 2:27 am

I appreciate the clarity and thoughtfulness you bring to this topic.

27529 Auto Glass April 11, 2024 at 7:06 pm

You’ve articulated your points with such finesse. Truly a pleasure to enjoy reading.

WIndshield Facts April 13, 2024 at 3:35 am

Making hard to understand topics accessible is a gift, and you have it. Thanks for sharing it with us.

auto glass setting tool April 13, 2024 at 9:45 pm

I appreciate the balance and fairness in The writing. Great job!

windshield replacement near 27332 April 16, 2024 at 10:50 am

Your work is truly inspirational. I appreciate the depth you bring to your topics.

top rated auto glass shop 27237 April 18, 2024 at 5:33 pm

Your work is truly inspirational. I appreciate the depth you bring to your topics.

Fayetteville auto glass shop April 19, 2024 at 8:03 am

Your work is truly inspirational. I appreciate the depth you bring to your topics.

28305 Auto Glass April 22, 2024 at 11:04 am

This piece was beautifully written and incredibly informative. Thank you for sharing!

28308 Auto Glass Quote April 23, 2024 at 6:49 am

This was a great enjoy reading—thought-provoking and informative. Thank you!

Top Rated Windshield Replacement 27616 April 29, 2024 at 5:34 am

I’m impressed by The ability to convey such nuanced ideas with clarity.

27609 Auto Glass Shop April 29, 2024 at 8:41 pm

Every post of Thes is a learning opportunity for me. Thanks for sharing The expertise.

Top Rated Auto Glass Replacement 27606 April 30, 2024 at 3:54 pm

Distilling hard to understand concepts into readable content, or what I like to call, a miracle.

27499 auto glass shop near me May 1, 2024 at 4:23 pm

The commitment to high quality content really shows. I’m always excited to read The work.

27495 auto glass May 1, 2024 at 8:02 pm

The attention to detail is remarkable, like a detective at a crime scene, but for words.

27417 Auto Glass Shop May 2, 2024 at 6:10 pm

The Writing is like a trusted compass, always pointing me in the direction of enlightenment.

car calibrator May 9, 2024 at 1:58 am

Unique viewpoints, because who needs echo chambers?

prodentim May 17, 2024 at 5:08 am

Prodentim: What is it? Some of the finest and highest quality ingredients are used to produce Prodentim, an oral health supplement

Auto glass shop near 28469 May 24, 2024 at 10:39 pm

The insights are as invigorating as a morning run, sparking new energy in my thoughts.

auto glass raleigh nc June 2, 2024 at 8:28 pm

What a fantastic read! Your ability to convey complex ideas in such a clear and engaging manner is truly impressive. I appreciate the thorough research and thoughtfulness that went into this post. It’s evident you care deeply about your readers’ understanding and growth. Thank you.

menophix June 5, 2024 at 3:08 pm

Wonderful paintings! That is the type of info that are supposed to be shared around the web. Shame on Google for now not positioning this put up upper! Come on over and discuss with my site . Thank you =)

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: